Made-to-print work starts from the grade that is written on the current revision, not from a convenient bar or wire that happens to be on the shelf. A “similar heading-quality steel”, a neighbouring stainless designation, or a copper alloy with a comparable machinability rating is not a substitute unless the print, or a written change to the print, allows it. Closing an RFQ by offering a near-equivalent is not a shortcut. It is a specification change, and it is treated as one.
The named grade is the grade that is quoted
Automotive fastener prints often name a carbon or alloy steel such as 1010, 1018, 10B21, 35CrMo, 42CrMo or SCM435, or they name a property class and leave the grade to a referenced standard. Those names are familiar examples, not a preferred stock list. Stainless prints may name 304, 316, 410, or an A2 or A4 designation; copper-alloy and aluminium prints name their own systems. In every case the grade on the revision is the grade that is quoted, as already stated in the notes on carbon and alloy steels and on stainless fasteners.
Equivalence between designations in different systems is not assumed without a stated equivalence on the print or in an attached specification. A 42CrMo bar is not offered in place of a named SCM435, or the reverse, just because both can be heat-treated to a similar class. Mixed notes — a 316 title block and an A2 head mark, for example — are flagged as conflicts, not resolved by choosing the easier melt.
Why a neighbour is not automatically acceptable
Two grades can share a carbon range and still differ in residual elements, hardenability, cold-heading behaviour, magnetism, corrosion resistance or the way they take a coating. Those differences matter to the route and to any later IMDS or certificate requirement. A substitution, including a change to or from a boron steel, or a change between an austenitic and a hardenable stainless, is a specification change and is not made on the shop floor. The same discipline is already applied in the note on material grade and certificates.
Starting stock also has to support the treatment. A steel specified for through-hardening to a high class, and a steel specified for a shallow case, are not interchangeable just because both can be headed. That point is developed further in the notes on heat treatment and on case hardening.
Certificates follow the specified grade
When a certificate is required, it has to match the grade and the condition that the print actually names. A certificate for a neighbouring grade is not a substitute, and a mill certificate is not rewritten to close a gap. EN 10204 3.1 evidence, when required, is confirmed per order, as in the note on documents confirmed per order. An IMDS entry, when required, likewise has to follow the specified grade and finish — see the separate note on IMDS and the material grade.
Open items are flagged, not filled from stock
If the print names only “steel”, only “stainless”, or only a property class without a grade where the standard leaves a choice, that is an open item. It is not a licence to select a preferred stock. The enquiry is returned with the missing point identified. A catalogue description, a previous informal sample, or a grade used on a sister part is not used to invent the missing call-out, as in the note on drawing revision control.
Process capability on a neighbour is not a reason to switch
A grade that heads more easily, that is already certified in the stores, or that has been used on a previous informal sample can look attractive when a quotation is being closed. That practical advantage is not a technical equivalence. If the customer wishes to change the grade, the change belongs on a revised print or in a written deviation that the customer issues. The supplier does not rewrite the title block in order to use a preferred melt, and a process-capability figure collected on a neighbouring grade is not transferred onto the specified grade as if they were the same material.
Volume and the proposed starting stock also belong in the enquiry, because a change of melt, of coating, or of heat-treatment route after samples have been approved can affect both the certificate and any IMDS entry. Those choices are stated in the quotation. First-article inspection, when required, should be planned on the production-intent grade and route, as in the note on first-article inspection. The current drawing revision remains the source of the material requirement in every case.
The enquiry should also make any already-approved deviation visible, including its expiry, its scope, and the revision to which it applies. A deviation written for one size, one finish, or one plant is not a general licence to substitute the grade on the next drawing. If no deviation exists, the quotation follows the named grade and lists open items; it does not invent a dual-grade option in order to keep a preferred melt in the route. Related revision discipline is already set out in the note on drawing revision control. Head marks, when they are required, are produced as specified for the named grade or class, not for the neighbour that was not accepted.
What to send with the RFQ
Send the current drawing revision, the material specification, and any customer standard that defines allowed grades or substitutions. If a written deviation already exists, attach it; if it does not, do not expect the quotation to create one. Volume and the proposed starting stock also belong in the enquiry, because a change of melt, of wire to bar, or of grade after samples have been approved is a process and specification change and is re-validated before serial release. Unspecified points will be flagged before production rather than assumed.
This article is a capability and commercial note. It is not a certificate, a dimensional data book, or evidence of customer approval. Catalogue type codes and example grades do not replace the customer’s item number, material specification or drawing revision.